Ep 21: Getting Found in Google & AI with Jonah Bautista of Atlanta Pro Network
What this episode covers
Jonah Bautista runs Atlanta Pro Network, a digital marketing agency that helps home service contractors show up in Google searches, map results, and AI tools like ChatGPT. He works with several Southern Shmooze certified businesses and built the new Shmooze website. Jonah explains the three ways customers find a business online, how Google decides who shows up in the map pack, why contractors still need a website in 2026, what leads cost on pay per lead platforms, and what every homeowner should verify before hiring someone off the internet.
Questions this episode answers
Tap a question. Each answer is a short summary with Jonah Bautista's own words underneath.
How Customers Find You Online
What are the three ways customers find a local business online?
Jonah Bautista explains that when someone searches for a service, they see three types of results. First, the sponsored ads at the top, where businesses pay 10 to 20 times more than a Shmooze membership to appear. Second, the map pack, which shows businesses closest to the searcher with good reputations. Third, the organic listings below, which depend on website SEO and take longer to build but feed into map pack rankings.
“The first three names that come up are usually going to be the sponsors. Those are people that are paying for ads. On average, they're going to pay about 10 to 20 times more in order to be able to get featured in those spots. The second strategy is essentially the map pack. The map pack is going to show the businesses ”Jonah Bautista
Does the number of Google reviews determine who ranks highest in search?
Jonah Bautista says the number of reviews is less important than most people think. Google's public ranking criteria puts review count at number nine on the list, so a business with six reviews can outrank one with a hundred reviews based on other factors like categories, services listed, and proximity.
“The actual number of ratings is actually number nine down the list. A company that only has like six reviews could actually beat out a company that has a hundred reviews based on some of these other variables.”Jonah Bautista
Google Business Profile Basics
What is the first thing a contractor should fix on their Google Business Profile?
Jonah Bautista says the first step is analyzing where the business ranks for different keywords in different locations using a heat map. Then he fixes the categories and services listed in the profile. Most businesses list five to ten services, but Jonah lists up to a hundred per category across ten categories, which opens the door to ranking for many more search terms. He can complete this process in about seven days.
“Google's essentially when a person types in any series of keywords, they're essentially going to be listed either higher or lower based on if you have those things listed in your services. By having multiple categories listed and having the potential for about 100 per category, that really opens up the door for how man”Jonah Bautista
Should I respond to every Google review my business gets?
Jonah Bautista strongly recommends responding to every review, positive or negative, within 24 hours. Google rewards businesses that actively manage their profiles and engage with customers. When reviewers mention the business name, the specific service, and the neighborhood, it helps Google recommend that business more often for similar searches in that area.
“By responding to every single review, it shows Google that you're an active business, that you actually are paying attention to your profile, you're paying attention to those relationships. You want to respond within 24 hours is kind of what Google recommends.”Jonah Bautista
Why does word of mouth alone not work to grow a contractor business?
Jonah Bautista says word of mouth proves a business does great work and people love them, but it is unpredictable and hard to scale. A contractor relying only on referrals has to hope people talk about them enough and that someone they know has the right problem at the right time. That makes it difficult to feed employees and family consistently, plan for retirement, or sell the business because the value is tied entirely to the owner's personal relationships.
“Word of mouth obviously means that you're doing great business. The problem is it's a very unpredictable way to run a business. You're essentially hoping that people will talk about you enough or that someone will come to someone you know with a problem that you can actually solve. It makes it very challenging to scale”Jonah Bautista
Why Contractors Need Websites
Does a small contractor still need a website in 2026 or is Google enough?
Jonah Bautista says a website is absolutely still necessary. It serves as the foundation for other platforms to source data, demonstrates trust, and lets homeowners meet the owner and team before making contact. The website also feeds information into Google and AI tools, helping a business rank for more searches and appear in more locations, not just the immediate area.
“Absolutely, the website serves so many different purposes and it's still the foundation for a lot of these other platforms to be able to source data. It's essentially demonstrates trust. It's a great tool to be able to show a company and to show homeowners, hey, yes, not only are we in your local area, but we know our ”Jonah Bautista
Cost Of Leads On Pay Platforms
What does a lead cost on Angi or HomeAdvisor and why do contractors quit?
Jonah Bautista says lead costs vary by trade. HVAC and roofing leads can cost $100 to $200 each because job values are higher. Smaller trades might pay $50 to $100 per lead. Contractors often quit because they pay for every lead whether they win the job or not, and the same lead is sold to multiple businesses at the same time, creating a race to the bottom.
“You can charge anywhere from $100 to $200 on average for those types of leads. You're literally looking at essentially dropping potentially a few thousand dollars, and you're essentially paying for it regardless if you land it or not. That lead is being sold to so many different people at the same time that it's almost”Jonah Bautista
How The Shmooze Concierge Works
How is the Shmooze concierge different from pay per lead services?
Jonah Bautista explains that the Shmooze concierge limits leads to Shmooze certified businesses only, so contractors compete with maybe 12 others instead of 300. The system uses a round robin, sending each request to one business at a time based on who specializes in that work. If the first contractor passes, it goes to the next. Every business gets an equal turn at incoming leads, and the cost is far lower than traditional lead platforms.
“Instead of competing with 300 other plumbers or 500 other plumbers, you're competing with like 12. The way the concierge system works is when a homeowner types in and says, hey, I'm looking for an electrician to solve this specific problem, it's first going to analyze what the homeowner's actually looking for and try t”Jonah Bautista
What does it take to become Shmooze certified?
Jonah Bautista says a business must serve Metro Atlanta, ideally working inside the perimeter even if they live outside it. They need to maintain a minimum number of positive reviews and stay visible and active online. If a business falls behind those benchmarks, the Shmooze checks in to see if there are systems or customer service issues to address, not to fix the business completely but to make sure people who love them can be heard.
“They have to serve Atlanta, Metro Atlanta, preferably even ITP. They have to maintain a minimum number of positive reviews and be visible, that you're actually getting the things that you're needing to do in order to become Shmooze certified. If the business does fall behind those numbers, that's kind of where we can a”Jonah Bautista
What Homeowners Should Check Before Hiring
What should I check before hiring a contractor I find online?
Jonah Bautista recommends checking reviews on the business profile, asking neighbors in the Shmooze for referrals, and verifying whether the trade requires a license. Licensed businesses follow code, carry insurance that protects both parties, and give homeowners legal protections if something goes wrong. He also stresses reading the contract carefully to make sure it protects the homeowner and clearly states how disagreements will be resolved.
“Having reviews on your Shmooze profile or having reviews on your Google page, that's like, okay, people are vouching for you. If it's a licensed industry, I think it's really valuable to make sure this person is following the law. They've got insurance that protects themselves and you. Look at your contracts. That docu”Jonah Bautista
Why should I hire a licensed contractor instead of saving money with someone unlicensed?
Jonah Bautista says licensed contractors follow government codes and carry insurance that protects the homeowner and the business. While unlicensed work might be cheaper, the risk is much higher. If the work is done incorrectly, there is no protection and serious consequences like a house fire become more likely. Licensing exists to ensure specialized technical work like plumbing, electrical, and roofing is done safely.
“If it's a licensed industry, make sure this person is following the law. They've established a lot where you have protections in place to know that this person is going by the code. You can get it cheaper going unlicensed, but you're also running a really high risk that if they do it the wrong way, your freaking house ”Jonah Bautista
What is the most important protection I have when hiring a contractor?
Jonah Bautista says the contract is the most important protection. It should clearly state what happens if there is a disagreement or if things do not work out, and how the parties will resolve it together. Homeowners should read contracts carefully and make sure they include protections, not just for the business but for the customer as well.
“Look at your contracts. There's always something that protects you and protects them within there. And if there's not something that protects you in there, make sure that you get it in there. That document is one of the most important agreements that you're going to have with any business.”Jonah Bautista
Worth remembering
- The map pack, not the number of reviews, is where most local customers find a contractor, and proximity matters more than review count.
- Listing up to ten categories and a hundred services per category in a Google Business Profile helps a contractor rank for far more search terms.
- Leads on Angi and HomeAdvisor cost $50 to $200 each, are sold to multiple businesses, and contractors pay whether they win the job or not.
- The Shmooze concierge sends each lead to one certified business at a time in round robin order, so every member gets an equal share of requests.
- Before hiring any contractor online, check reviews, verify licensing if required, ask neighbors for referrals, and read the contract carefully.
- A website is still essential in 2026 because it feeds data to Google and AI, builds trust, and helps a business rank beyond the immediate neighborhood.
Written from the episode transcript. The full conversation is in the player above.